Find a game by title, genre or studio. Compare reviews, release dates and trailers.
Similar to COLONY 2 — based on shared gameplay and genres, popularity and reviews. The original game is excluded from the results. Remove comparison
The first 500 games were considered for comparison of 1,993 initial matches. Similar games among them: 196. Refine the filters to narrow the selection.
The First Seal is a 1–4 player co-op psychological horror game. Explore an isolated Victorian estate, operate paranormal equipment, manage your sanity, and uncover the truth behind its imprisoned entity before the house claims you too.
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Mystery
Night Plane is a job-sim horror game where you work as a flight attendant on a doomed plane. Check tickets, serve passengers, and decide who stays onboard as demons hide among innocent souls. Naturally, management says it’s your problem.
Shared features: Horror, Management, Mystery
VHS Tapes is a 1-4 player, online co-op horror. Experience a collection of mysterious video tapes, each one containing completely different stories, locations, puzzles and nightmares to endure. INSERT. PRESS PLAY.
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Mystery
“High Pay, Simple Work, Room and Board Provided.” Trapped in an isolated room, monitor hotel CCTV and report anomalies. As the days repeat, strange events and memories of the past begin to connect. Follow the hotel's manual. It may be your only guide to survival.
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Mystery
Anomaly Express is a 1–4 player co-op psychological horror aboard a winter train. Spot anomalies, survive deadly encounters, and uncover the supernatural force behind this endless journey.
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Mystery
Out of the Shadows is a 2–4 player online co-op horror escape game. Explore unsettling locations, uncover their stories, solve cooperative and asymmetric puzzles, and survive the hostile inhabitants of places your team was never meant to enter.
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Mystery
For years, you cared for your mother until her illness began to destroy your life. Her weak voice, her exhausted appearance, her fading consciousness... Are you willing to keep enduring this?
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Mystery
Your wife is dead, but you can hear her voice on the phone. Follow the coordinates, explore abandoned locations, answer calls from the phone booth, and make your way deeper and deeper into the abyss. Every new call brings you closer to the truth... but you may not be ready to hear it.
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Mystery
A dark Metroidvania-style shooter with dangerous bosses and surreal horror. Explore twisted locations, search for weapons, and save your wife from the clutches of demonic forces.
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Mystery
Look for sister. Die. Start again. Avoid stalker. Die. Hide. Die. Seek keys. Die. Sneak. Die. Reach final area. Survive. Repeat. Do you have what it takes to escape the horror of the White Mask Mansion?
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Mystery
Sam agrees to help his friends by staying the night in their house while they leave for urgent business. Outside, a heavy rainstorm rages, with loud thunderclaps shaking the walls and creating an oppressive atmosphere.
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Mystery
Scared by Squares is a psychological horror game and an experiment in fear: can a simple cube scare you? Explore unsettling liminal spaces, solve environmental puzzles, survive hidden traps, and hunt anomalies in a world of corrupted geometry.
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Mystery
Desecrated Deck is a first-person psychological horror card game where you face a spectral opponent in a forbidden occult ritual of Rock, Paper, Scissors, powerful Item Cards, and supernatural Perks. Win the game — or discover what happens when you don’t.
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Mystery
A found footage horror game where you need to piece together a timeline in chronological order of a Kaiju incident that occurred.
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Mystery
Tarpit is a psychological indie horror game where you have to make TAR to rescue your friend from danger. Beware of the forces in your surroundings. The forces definitely see you... but do you see them?
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Mystery
Explore the LeBlanc hotel and reveal hidden illusions through Eugene’s camera, an archivist. Follow in Laura’s footsteps, an investigator working on the disappearance of Eugene's sister, 20 years ago. Armed with a camera and discretion, can you discover the hotel’s heart and its mysteries?
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Mystery
You wake up to find yourself standing before an old house. The painful memories buried deep within your heart suddenly return. You don’t remember it well, but you used to live here. This is where it happened.
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Mystery
The rules do not lie. The guests who obeyed them are still in the ledger, and nowhere else. An inn on the border of the afterlife; each night, another rule. Lower your eyes, cover your ears, judge what slips in. Some nights, what comes wears the name of a thing the rules describe. Obey, or doubt.
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Mystery
You are trapped inside an endless house shaped by memory and guilt. Use mysterious masks to reveal hidden layers of reality, identify anomalies and escape a psychological time loop.
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Mystery
Your boyfriend is a tied up corpse now, but at least he still loves you?
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Mystery
A Thai anomaly-spotting horror game. In 1997, a man swore something was in his house. His psychiatrist said no. Now the case is yours. Go through his old CCTV tapes, report every anomaly, and figure out why this case never made sense.
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Story rich
Terrible Lizards is a horror parkour game set against the backdrop of an old Route 66 attraction… with something dark and sinister lurking below. To escape, you’ll need to move fast, navigate challenging terrain, and uncover what Dalton’s Dinos is really hiding. You’d better start running.
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Story rich
Parasomnia Verum 2 is a psychological horror game about Maddy's repeating nightmares crawling into reality.
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Story rich
THIS IS NOT A GAME. IT’S A RITUAL DISGUISED AS ONE. House 12 was abandoned after a massacre, a satanic ceremony, and the disappearance of everyone involved. Later, the surviving archive resurfaced, only for you to find it. Every ritual requires consent. Clicking "Wishlist it" may be yours.
Shared features: Horror, Supernatural, Story rich
Popularity is the total number of Steam reviews, not sales or concurrent players. Activity is the average net daily growth in reviews over the longest stable window of up to 7 days; it requires at least 12 hours of history and data updated within the last 72 hours. It measures discussion volume, not sentiment. Anticipation for upcoming games is measured separately. Missing measurements do not mean a game is unpopular.
